Celebrity Justice
Birkhead Wins Legal Skirmish with Opri

Larry Birkhead and Debra Opri will go before a jury in their bitter fee dispute.

TMZ has obtained a ruling from a Los Angeles County Superior Court judge, in which Opri's argument that the dispute be heard privately by an arbitrator was shut down.

Opri was banking on the judge accepting a provision in her fee agreement, which called for arbitration. But the judge noted that "Birkhead's declaration contains great detail about the facts surrounding his introduction to Opri. ... He states that he was introduced to Opri through a reporter with MSNBC [Rita Cosby], and Opri told him that he would not be charged any fees 'because the publicity from her representation of me would greatly benefit her legal career.'"

The judge was not impressed that Opri never dealt with Birkhead's allegations of fraud, duress and waylaying hundreds of thousands of dollars he earned. The judge said, "where a party provides weaker evidence when it could have provided stronger evidence, the (judge) may distrust the weaker evidence." In other words, Opri should have addressed Birkhead's allegations rather than just saying he signed an agreement.

Birkhead's lawyer Michael Trope said, "I'm happy with the result." See ya in court!



Reader Comments

(Page 5 of 7) Previous 15 Comments | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

61. THE WEIGHT OF THE EVIDENCE SUPPORTS THE DETERMINATION
THAT THERE IS NO ARBITRATION AGREEMENT IN THIS CASE,
AND THE PETITION SHOULD BE DENIED. AMONG OTHER THINGS
WHERE A PARTY PROVIDES WEAKER EVIDENCE WHEN IT COULD
HAVE PROVIDED STRONGER EVIDENCE , THE FACT-FINDER MAY
DISTRUST THE WEAKER EVIDENCE
THE AGREEMENT ON PAGES 7-THROUGH 9 CLEARLY A SEPARATE
AGREEMENT ON PAGES 7 THROUGH 9 IT IS NOT CERTAIN WHEN
THESE NUMBERS WERE PLACED ON THE PAGES. FURTHERMORE,
THE SUBSEQUENT MEDIA AGREEMENT REFERS TO A SINGLE
AGREEMENT THE ONE BEARING A DATE OF SEPTEMBER 30,2006
NAMELY, THE SECOND ONE WITHOUT AN ARBITRATION CLAUSE

Posted at 6:33PM on Sep 6th 2007 by Sighhh

62. I HAVE JUST READ A FEW COMMENTS,AND WILL ANSWER,IN THE FIRST PLACE EVERY POLL GIVEN LARRY IS THE WINNER .MOST OF THEM ARE 80 PERCENT FOR LARRY.THAT IS THE COURT OF PUPLIC OPI.NION.IF RITA ,S BOOK IS SELLING LIKE HOT CAKES PEOPLE ARE PAYING FOR LIES,SO FAR NO REAL TAPE HAS SHOWED UP WHAT IS IT$18.00 I LOVE IT.THERE IS A SUCKER BORN EVERY DAY,MOST OF THE BOOK IS PURE HYPE.BUTIF ANYONE WANTS TO PAY THAT MONEY FOR HYPE MORE SHE CAN BE SUED FOR,AND THAN DANNIELYNN WILL GET SOMETHING FROM THOSE SLEEZE BAGS

Posted at 6:34PM on Sep 6th 2007 by BEVERLY

63. In other words. OPRI your such a LOSERRRRRRRR

Posted at 6:35PM on Sep 6th 2007 by Sighhh

64. Yeah Larry!

Posted at 6:39PM on Sep 6th 2007 by cal

65. why would he trust her anyway. She is a lawyer for Micheal "Child Molester" Jackson & His mother. She has no morals.

Posted at 6:51PM on Sep 6th 2007 by animal lover

66. Laurie Birkhead the zit face didn't win anything.

Posted at 6:54PM on Sep 6th 2007 by sha la la

67. Thats a Big win for Larry. OMG OPRI. Arent you embarassed YET.?
The Judge says. your evidence is WEAK. no wonder he . and all the rest FIRED
yo A-S-S,

Man for reals OPRI and CROSBY and Mommy dearest Virgie. is like watching the 3 stooges .
I would not watch any channel who puts Crosby on. thats a disgrace
I would NEVER hire OPRI as an lawyer unless I want to LOSSE the case
Mommy Dearest EXPLAINS it all.







Posted at 6:55PM on Sep 6th 2007 by Sighhh

68. OUTSTANDING!! Hope Deb and Rita end up as CELLMATES....Bet we
can guess which one will be smuggling in her strap-on!
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!
Better start saving those ROYALTIES, you phoney gravel-voiced wanna-be-noticed
BE-OTCH!!!
And by the way, Opri, you greedy wanna-be paralegal, they don't serve LOBSTERS where you're going, just tuna tacos!!!!
PURE GREED AND EVIL..........

Posted at 7:09PM on Sep 6th 2007 by justice4dannilynn

69. WTG~!!! Larry~!! The money-grubbing smut-beasts "true-colors" are becoming more clear with each passing day.........Opri should be disbarred....and Cosby, is a wretched lonely woman lusting for attention, she worships sleaze.....Cosby's reputation for smut, speaks for itself.

Posted at 6:11PM on Sep 7th 2007 by LucieLee

70. YOU GO LARRY - TAKE THIS STUPID FAME FETCHING LAWYER??? TO TASK. SHE SHOULD BE DISBARED.

Posted at 7:48PM on Sep 6th 2007 by buzzie

71. >>zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

EVERYBODY IS TALKING A SEXUAL RELATIONSHIP 'TWEEN
LARRY AND HOWARD..BUT, AFTER READING THESE LAST 2
ARTICLES.. IT MIGHT BE INTERESTING TO FIND OUT JUST
HOW "CONNECTED" ARE COSBY AND OPRI?

Posted at 1:27PM on Sep 8th 2007 by PJ

72. Rita...Opri.....Virgie......Jackie H.......All these LIARS WILL BE EXPOSED!!!!

Posted at 7:56PM on Sep 6th 2007 by Opri's career if OVER!

73. Sooooo....TIRED of these Losers.......RITA....OPRI....JACKIE.....VIRGIE......GO AWAY......GO AWAY........


Sorry Larry that you and your little Angel have these LOSERS attacking your life......

Posted at 8:00PM on Sep 6th 2007 by Byyyyeeee Opri.......

74. The book is pure junk. I hope Rita Cosby is suited to the limit. I think Rita, Opri, and Vergie and Hatten are all in on this for revenge. Rita is probably Opi's gay lover. We know there is some kind of connection there. Opi gave Rita client information about Larry, this is illegal to do. Vergie invited Rita Cosby to Anna funeral. They had to kick Rita out of the house following the funeral. She fought going instead of just leaving like she was asked. Rita, Opri, Hatten and Vergie all are vengeful women. I hope thay all get what is coming to them. No wonder Anna hated her mother.

Posted at 8:04PM on Sep 6th 2007 by The book is junk. Plain gossip. Written via third party he said, she said

75. Larry, anyone who has every received a bill from an attorney is giving you a standing ovation right now!!!!!

Posted at 8:34PM on Sep 6th 2007 by whatever you say

Previous 15 Comments | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments